Shop Cheddar - Flavored Store/Fresh Cut Cheese/Cheddar - FlavoredSort byWe recommendNewest arrivalsPrice: Low to HighPrice: High to LowName: A to ZName: Z to AFiltersClear allFiltersClear allShow itemsShow itemsCheddar Blue - Cheddar CheeseCheddar Blue - Cheddar Cheese$11.99Blueberry, Cranberry & Cherry CheddarBlueberry, Cranberry & Cherry Cheddar$11.99Cheddar - Mild, Medium, SharpCheddar - Mild, Medium, Sharp$7.99Extra Sharp White Natural Cheddar Aged 3 to13 YearsExtra Sharp White Natural Cheddar Aged 3 to13 Years$9.99Olive Cheddar CheeseOlive Cheddar Cheese$8.99Hot Cheese Wisconsin's "Big Three"Hot Cheese Wisconsin's "Big Three"$12.99Extra Sharp Yellow Natural Cheddar Aged 2 to 20 YearsExtra Sharp Yellow Natural Cheddar Aged 2 to 20 Years$8.99